[Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner

I got my eyeliner in dark brown (#5). I noticed that there is a little bit of glitter in this color (very pretty!). I also like how easy it is to apply this liner smoothly on my eyelids. My only gripe is that the liner fades after a couple hours on my lids - however, my eyes tear up pretty often so this might not be issue for others.

I purchased this in both black and brown. I have oily lids and eyes that tend to water at inopportune moments, so I'm always searching for waterproof, sweatproof, smudge-proof liners. Especially since I love the look of tightlining, but I haven't been able to find a liner that doesn't give me raccoon eyes in two hours. Sad to say, this liner is not it. With regular lining outside my lash line, it doesn't stay as a line, and I can no longer see it after two hours. It smudges decently if you do it right away (I can use it as a shadow on my aegyo-sal), and doesn't smudge after setting (until my skin starts working its magic). It is just my eyes, though (yes, even with a primer). I tested it on my arm, and it lasted all day before finally starting to fade with repeated rubbing. This may work just fine for you if you don't have oily lids and watery eyes.

Out of all the eyeliner I've tried, this is the best one. It's stays on my eyelid 99%. I do notice some spots here and there, but it's not that noticeable & I don't care, so I'm fine with it. I also love that it doesn't budge. I'm going to purchase it again.

i don’t normally wear makeup at all but this is really nice! i got the Black one and it’s super pigmented and draws an uninterrupted smooth line. the flatter tip definitely makes it easier to draw a sharp line as well! would love to repurchase in a different color.